Saturday, March 11, 2023

SHOE BOX MEMORIES

 

Me and Alan singing harmonies into a single microphone. That would be 1976 probably. One of our first gigs, some youth club in Sheffield.

We had very different musical influences, but somehow a conviction that we could blend them into a music that was distinctively ours.

The blues guys were my contribution to the mix. Don't get too fancy. Get the tone right and play from the heart. Can't tell you how much those memories mean to me.

 



Another page from my old history of architecture notebook. Continuing my analysis of the Fagus Factory by Walter Gropius. I really must find time for a little #bimpencil study of this.

Gropius actually took over from another architect on this project and inherited the basic plan layout. His job, in the first instance was to make the elevations look better, which is kind of ironic given the usual modernist mantra about "form follows function"

Maybe we should just accept that practical problems and the pursuit of beauty are intertwined in our work. Maybe we (architects) should be less grandiose in our rhetoric. But I can't really see that happening.

This diagram from over 30 years ago describes the origin of the previous architect's confusion. Wrapping the corner when the grid is 7 by 5. You can get boxed into making an awkward transition and breaking the rhythm of the facade. One approach is to make a grand gesture on the corner but this is a factory so he just fudged it.

 



Third sketch in this series. Fagus Factory by Walter Gropius. My analysis from 1990 of the original architect's solution to wrapping the corner on a 7 x 5 grid.

He fits three arched window bays into a 7m bay two into a 5m bay. All very "honest" and pragmatic but resulting in an awkward change of rhythm at the corner.

Gropius comes up with a clever sleight of hand that requires glazing the corner. This is often portrayed as a statement of principle, the birth of the "machine aesthetic" and the first curtain wall.

My suggestion, based on reading I did at the time... it was more of a geometry puzzle. Probably a lot of sketches before the way to achieve regularity popped up. And it required a glazed corner, which suggested the kind of continuous glazing he had experienced in Behrens office at the AEG Turbine Hall.

I may be wrong, but it suggests a particular solution to a particular problem. When that becomes a trademark style to roll out repeatedly, the game changes again. To me, his later work is patchy and less convincing.

 


 

From lock-downs to student debt relief, the so-called left has abandoned the working class to help out young college-educated radicals. (such as I was 50 years ago) Politicians are subsidising their former selves, paying off the activist bullies that back them up.

Why not spend a few billions on apprenticeship schemes for those who are more practically inclined instead of helping out the laptop class and encouraging ever more young people to "study race and gender"

Don't get mad. I'm just exploring another way of framing this "news story" having read the BBC version.

Where do I stand? Still figuring it out, but promoting apprenticeships and encouraging people to work with their hands makes a lot of sense. That's what helped me to get my head out of the clouds and find a positive direction in life.

 



Two images from 1981 when I was 30 years old. Two sides of a coin that flipped almost overnight yet both aspects of me lived on.

They are both adventurers but in different ways. The adventures of the mind came naturally to a boy who loved to draw. The challenges of physical work on building sites and of moving to Africa as a volunteer teacher were efforts of will, offshoots of belated teenage rebellion.

I slept on those thin mattresses on a cement floor as the only "non-black" member of an experimental school in newly independent Zimbabwe. I was naive and idealistic but open to the school of hard knocks.

The drawing is from a few months earlier, living in Sheffield, seven years of building work behind me after dropping out of an architecture career in disillusion. I had weathered the storm of manual labour, skills acquisition, blending into working class culture. Where next?

Perhaps I had a future in the imaginative world of conceptual graphics, linking together disparate ideas of time, scale, spheres, the history of everything. I wonder where that might have taken me, but instead I flew to Africa and never looked back.

 


 

 

Friday, March 3, 2023

MIES ON MY BALCONY

September 2015. A really simplistic Revit model of the Bank of England, as it was in 1830 at the end of John Soane's long tenure as their third architect. Of course I went on to develop a much more detailed model over the next couple of years. With significant contributions by others.

I was just trying to wrap my head around the complexity of a building that had evolved over a century of constant expansion and reorganisation. Hence the colour-coded slabs over the various interlocking zones.

Then there is the screen wall, subtly different from the one in place today. It was totally rebuilt by Herbert Baker, streamlined and shuffled around. There is no single drawing or photograph that shows it exactly as it was in 1830. It was fun to figure out.

Finally the banking halls. Five variations on a theme. Fascinating geometry. Top lit masonry vaults for fire protection and security. What a journey of discovery that whole period was. #bimpencil at its best.

 



 

I'm reading this book about Mies that I found on Kindle a while ago. Helps me fall asleep 🤣🤣🤣

Seriously though, he was an interesting character, coming from a fairly humble background, compared to say Gropius.

A few years ago I started a Revit model of the Tugendhat House. You learn such a lot by scrounging around for references, approximating dimensions, gradually "joining the dots" of how a building works.

The joy and the learning is in the figuring out process. Stumbling around and making mistakes. Then realising WHY, you made a wrong assumption.

 



 

In 2017, I used my Tugendhat House model in a conference presentation that ran through different ways that I have customised Revit families in the Planting category.

I used the Mies villa to illustrate my "Flat Trees"... Diagrammatic and lightweight, used here to help bring a very crude, early-stage model to life. Most people think of Revit as a hard-edged solution for documentation, not intuitive enough for quick broad-brush studies.

These are Enscape renderings given a quick burst of post-processing on my phone. I wish there were some trees in the lower view though. 🤣🤣🤣

 



 

Another look at the Revit model of the Tugendhat House by Mies van Dr Rohe that I built a few years ago. Very basic. Would be nice to take it a bit further.

It's an unusual site and an unusual layout but very familiar to us a century later. You can see once again the sort of graphic images that are possible with my "Flat Trees" families. Nothing fancy, just a couple of thin extrusions at right angles, and cad imports on the same vertical planes.

In the cutaway perspective you can see the basement room mentioned by Alfredo, commenting on a previous post. Some of the large glass windows in the room retract into this space via motorised sliding mechanism. A bit like garage doors in reverse, but without the need to tilt into the horizontal plane.

Bedrooms on the upper, entrance level, living spaces below and a wooded slope dropping away quite steeply connected to the terrace by broad steps.

 



 

Crescent moon, clothes line, pigeon mesh, fake wind towers, fake falconry. International City, Dubai... My little world of urban sunsets. #dubai #waywebuild #photography

 




 

Friday, February 24, 2023

LOOKING BACK

 

A snapshot from my pocket notebook from a time when I was struggling with the physical demands of manual labour on building sites, but determined to reject the world of corporate architecture that I had glimpsed as an undergraduate.

Difficult to convey that journey of early manhood. Growing our hair long was such a big deal in the late 60s. Political awareness seemed so black and white. Testosterone perhaps 🙄

Thankfully I was lured into a world of practical skills, learning to respect the capabilities of those who had done less well than me at school but learned to handle harsh physical realities.

I'm so glad that I didn't just follow the tram lines that would have kept me in architect's offices for the rest of my life. No disrespect for those who took that route, but I wasn't ready for it.

Had to pursue my "hero's journey" first, and it was a blast for sure.

 



 

The year was 1988. We had moved into a new house, with a guest wing that would allow my mum and dad to come on extended visits and there was a swimming pool in the front garden.

My mum had always been a strong swimmer. Wonderful pic of her in the pool with Joe.

I had moved from curriculum development to the University. Challenging times. I had to design a course to upgrade teachers to degree level and accept the first intake of students, all within three weeks.

The section details of steel frames were deduced from studying the building where I gave my lectures. Desperately developing material to use in class and working late into the night. I've no idea how I pulled through that period.

The house plans were requested by a colleague and I just didn't know how to say no. At this stage I really had no intention of resuming my architecture career. But in retrospect these were the first baby steps back in that direction.

 


 

 

Revit work from almost 14 years ago. I was still trying to convince the firm that we could use BIM from an early design stage. Eventually I decided that there were better uses for my energy. The concept design team is used to a certain way of working, and to some extent I get it, although the burden dumped on the BIM team is glossed over, and it hurts our bottom line for sure.

But this was a great project. A huge piece of topography and multiple linked models. It was very demanding on the hardware we had at the time, but we did use the capabilities of Revit to resolve difficult site planning problems on rugged terrain and convince our engineers to rethink some of their solutions.

Big thanks to Simon and Nandish for comradeship throughout and for trusting me to deliver on my side of the bargain. Props to Hrishi and Mani who were footsoldiers on that team and have since progressed to BIM leadership roles in the practice.

 



 

These sketches must be from 1970. First year at University College and I had befriended Peter Jeffree. He helped to introduce me to Blues and Jazz, and we had quite wide-ranging shared interests.

This sheet is a set of ideas for paintings. Various themes running through here. Not sure if I ever showed this to Pete, but we must have talked about art and the potential for mundane items like soil stacks to inspire moody, semi-abstract compositions.

Lots of architectural ideas here and the hint of something lurking just around the corner. I'm starting to think that I'm just about ready to follow through on these ideas, more than 50 years later.

 



 

Letraset, rotring stencil and a small freehand sketch. Photocopy as required.

I guess this is from 1978. Hand crafted letterhead for my quotes, such as they were. Plus a photograph of demolition stage on an attic conversion job. Take out the skylight, build a dormer, box in the top of the stair for sound and fire reasons.

Even at the time, I was dubious about those flat roofed dormers. It was a quick face-lift, improving headroom and lighting, but how long did they last? Roofing felt on chipboard at a nominal slope.

Happy memories though. Better than spending my twenties in an office. Can't beat getting your hands dirty on a building site at that age.